It’s no secret I am an avid reader of Sarah J Maas. If you’ve been around since the beginning, you’ll have seen my reread of ACOTAR and first-read of Crescent City showing up in Reading Recaps back in 2023. In the years since, I’ve wanted to reread Throne of Glass, but never managed to pull the trigger. Until this year, following the podcast announcement of new ACOTAR books. Not only did I finally reread the series, but I was able to read alongside friends who were reading for the first time, which made returning to this world even more special. And there truly is something special about Throne of Glass, not just because it was my first.
And yes, technically my first Maas book was A Court of Thorns and Roses, when it published in 2015, before realizing it was the start of a series. I decided to let the series grow before revisiting, to minimize the cliffhanger effects. It was another 2 years before I decided to pick up Throne of Glass in 2017, quickly falling in love with the world and characters, reading my way through the published books leading up to the publication of Kingdom of Ash in 2018, by which time I was also finally reading ACOTAR {significant for a small detail during a pivotal event in Kingdom of Ash}.
NOTE: There will be potential spoilers in the rest of this post, but I’ll try to keep it minimal.
This is not a review, nor will I be going into a lot of detail about particular events or characters. If you’re looking for a plot summary, there are many options out there that are far better than anything I’d write up. Instead, this is my thoughts and feelings about the rereading experience. My personal journey into the Maasverse, beginning with my first – and favorite – series.
According to Goodreads, there’s a lot of flailing in my first reviews, and I remember gushing conversations to a librarian friend about the kickassery of Aelin. By the final book, I was able to write a more coherent review, and a lot of what I said then is still true after the reread.
November 2018 thoughts:
The overarching theme of this whole series, to me, is that fight the truth as you may – the most important thing, the most important truth, is Love. Of People and Home. Because Love is the motivator that defies Hate and darkness. And that is always worth fighting for.
November 2026 thoughts:
It’s even better the second time around.
And my takeaway of the overarching theme is the same:
Love is the most powerful force in the world – in any and every world. And little acts of kindness will grow into a tidal wave of Love and Light to wash away the darkness.

My first reading, I was caught up in the power Aelin possessed. Not just her magical power, but the skills and strength she gained as an assassin. I loved that the scrappy “nobody” assassin was also a queen, and more fuel was added to the fire of wanting a sword of my own. That fighting spirit – the unconquerable, unbreakable spirit – caught my heart in ways I still can’t explain. In this second reading, having been through more life, I still deeply appreciated Aelin’s sheer strength and survival. But more than that, I was impressed by how – in spite of everything – she was willing to reach out, to extend kindness, in small ways that rippled out, setting things in motion for that better world. In so many ways, this series is about the far-reaching and long-lasting effects of acts of kindness, no matter how small.
This might be something for a future post, but it also feels like the right fit here, in context of Aelin and her companions, and the long dark journey they survived. One of the many reasons I read fantasy is because you can actually fight the forces of darkness – in this case, literal darkness. I can’t fight all the battles I’d like to in this world, and there are some things you can’t fight in a tangible way. But in these, and so many other fantasy novels? You can. The characters can – and do.
A Few Thoughts on Crossover Elements {Spoilerish}
If you’ve read ACOTAR and Crescent City, you know there’s a substantial crossover between the worlds/series. Having read Throne of Glass, I also picked up on potential crossover elements, when Lidia explained the naming of her children and her family’s distant heritage. Plus, the whole burning stag aspect. Whether these threads are picked up again – who knows? But SJM is a master of hiding tiny details in plain sight and bringing them forward later with a flourish. I will not be surprised if more direct ties to Aelin & Company are revealed in books to come.
I also found it hilarious that early on, in the very first book, we’re introduced to wyrdmarks and the idea of portals and etc, while it took ages for these details to come out in the others. I read Throne of Glass first, you’d think I’d remember that information and put the pieces together myself – but I did not. Honestly, I never even thought about crossovers at all until Cresent City pulled that stunt. I did note the {unnamed} appearance of Rhys/Feyre during Aelin’s “free fall,” but thought it more a wink to readers than a hint for deeper layering. So, it was very interesting going into the reread knowing the potential was there and “looking for clues” or significant details. Especially during Aelin’s “free fall,” as she was seeing glimpses of all the other worlds.
As I begin {another} reread of ACOTAR, I’m keeping my eyes open for more tidbits and breadcrumbs. And when I get to Crescent City again, I feel certain I’ll pick up on more, since I spent most of my first read dealing with the “culture shock” of the futuristic setting. Fear not: there will be future posts concerning both series, and potentially one concerning the new books – when I get to them. I don’t mind delaying the reading of the newly released ACOTAR because the rereading is such a delight and by the time I’m ready to pick it up the next one should be available as well. Strategizing, my friends, strategizing.
Have you read any of Sarah J Maas’s books?
If so, what’s your favorite series? Favorite character?